Love Coffee? French Press Reviews

22 Sep
Love Coffee

photo by Ahmed Rabea.

A few months ago, my coffee maker started dying.  I’m a daily coffee drinker, and, although I don’t like to admit it, I don’t think I function well in the morning without it.  Obviously, immediate action was necessary.  I started researching various options including those fancy Tassimo and Keurig machines.  The more reviews I read, the more I felt guided toward a french press.  Coffee connoisseurs everywhere I looked claimed that this is the best way to brew coffee and bring out the best flavor.  I also liked the idea of eliminating a machine on my counter top, and it seems a little more “green” since it doesn’t require electricity or paper filters.  After reading MANY reviews, I settled on the beauty below from Frieling.  Sure it was pricey at $79.99, but I was expecting fine German quality and a lasting & beautiful press.

It arrived and I was in love.  It made FABULOUS coffee!  The best I think I ever made in my home!  Woohoo!  Plus, it was pretty.  Right?

Fast forward almost three months exactly.  A tornado touched down half a block away from our house (I kid you not), and we were without power for 50ish hours.  I needed coffee.  But that beauty above? Broke.  The press mechanism on the inside has a screen/filter that screws onto the plunger stick (these are NOT official part names).  The threads were stripped and they would no longer go together.  After TWO MONTHS!!  So I emailed the company.  I told them that I had only purchased the press three months earlier, that I loved it, and was very disappointed with this problem.  A lovely customer service representative responded with this curt email message:

It is a normal wear and tear. You may order replacement parts by calling us at 800-827-2592. I’ve attached a parts list for your reference.

Seriously.  That was the extent of the message/service.

Excuse me?? Standard wear? After three months? I sent another email, basically saying: So, you’re telling me that I can look forward to purchasing this $6 part (plus shipping) every three months if I continue to use your product since this is “normal wear & tear”??  I remain disappointed.  Their response:

I don’t want  you think that our products are not of high quality. Please let me explain. Being that the treads on the French Presses are small, if taken apart on daily basis it can strip them quicker. It is not necessary to take the plunger assembly apart after each use to clean. You can put the attached assembly in the dishwasher  or even wash and rinse by hand without taking it apart each time. This will help prevent premature stripping. I apologize for any inconvenience.

Notice they’re still essentially saying it’s my fault (after only three months).  I responded with:

I’ve had it for 3 months and took it completely apart twice. I think it should stand up to that kind of use MUCH longer.  It also seems like you should stand behind the parts at least a year.  I remain disappointed.

Their response:

I was only trying to troubleshoot. My goal is you make you a happy customer, not disappointed. Generally, the part that we see get stripped is the “Y” shaped bottom plate. We will send you one at no cost to resolve the problem. If for some reason it doesn’t resolve the issue, please contact us and we will work on getting it resolved. Please provide us with you complete mailing address and we will get this out to you ASAP.

Um….Frieling people? TROUBLESHOOTING means asking more questions and offering to help immediately.  Not after 3 messages. TROUBLESHOOTING would have initially asked, “How many times have you taken the press apart for cleaning in three months?”  EXCELLENT SERVICE wouldn’t have asked any questions and would simply stand behind the product by immediately offering a $6 replacement part at no charge since it had only been three months.


So, I had no idea how long I needed to wait to get this part, and I need my coffee in the morning!  I decided to give Starbucks new Via instant coffee a try.  I trucked to Starbucks to check it out.  I was skeptical about the taste of instant coffee from the get-go, but when I saw the price of Via, I seriously began reconsidering.  While I was debating, I noticed this Bodum press for only $19.99.  Notice the price difference from the Frieling ($79.99)?  Yeah.  I was concerned about the Bodum’s quality, but decided to give it a try.  I decided I could buy this for the cost of buying two packages of Via, and I could either keep it as a backup press, or sell it when the Frieling parts came.



Surprisingly, I love the Bodum more than the Frieling! It presses smoothly EVERY TIME.  The coffee NEVER splurts out the spout when pressing.  I never have floaty grounds in my coffee.  It’s super easy to clean.  The interior press mechanism seems to go together and STAY together much better than the Frieling.  The coffee tastes just as amazing.  After I press it, I pour it in an insulated carafe, and it stays warm all day.

Moral of the story?  Buy the Bodum.  Save some bucks.  Enjoy some wonderful coffee!

You’re welcome.


*Disclaimer: I was not paid in any way for this review and I have no association with either company, other than the products from them that I purchased.  The views expressed in this post are simply my opinion based on personal use and experience.


Posted by on September 22, 2010 in Favorite Things, Product Reviews


8 responses to “Love Coffee? French Press Reviews

  1. becky

    September 22, 2010 at 11:22 pm

    that is a load of bullshit! omg. i’d be so pissed too!

  2. psychmamma

    September 22, 2010 at 11:31 pm

    In fairness, they DID finally send the part at no charge, but the service up to that point was just sad.

    It was a happy ending, though, since I found I LOVE french pressed coffee and the Bodum (for less $) is fantastic!

  3. Dre

    September 24, 2010 at 11:20 pm

    I LOVE my Bodum. I remember when you were asking on twitter about french presses, and I can’t recall if I suggested the Bodum, although I did rave about french presses in general. The best thing about the Bodums being so inexpensive is that I went ahead and bought the big one AND the small one, so I could make single cups or more, depending on if I was having coffee alone or not.

    Stinks that a company with such an expensive product was such a pain in the rear!!

  4. domestic Extraordinaire

    October 26, 2010 at 11:58 pm

    I have a bodum and I LOVE it. I got the Keurig when I saw it for a really big discount. We use this one more often than the Bodum as I am inpatient to wait for the water to get hot to put into the press and I have the reusable filter for my Keurig so its a bit greener than the usual Keurig.

    Love the new look of the site!

  5. psychmamma

    October 27, 2010 at 12:35 am

    Domestic Extraordinaire –

    Ha! And I have found the press to be quicker than my old coffee maker! Water boils in a snap, & PRESTO! Yummy coffee! Mostly, though? I just don’t like all the flavored stuff anyway, so a Keurig just didn’t seem to make sense for “plain old” coffee. =)

    P.S. Thanks for the lovely site compliment!

  6. Summer Holeman

    May 23, 2013 at 11:30 pm

    thank you for thi review. I found it very helpful in my search to replace our failing coffee maker.

  7. jimboskype1939

    June 8, 2013 at 7:58 am

    Wall Mart has a Mr. Coffee Press for about $20,00 I have not tried it yet but will do the test this AM. and give you the results later.

  8. Carl

    September 25, 2014 at 5:33 pm

    Glass French presses are far too fragile, and dangerous when the break, and they do that often. The Frieling or a Bodum stainless steel model is far, far safe though more expensive. Factor in the number of times you replace a Bodum glass beaker and you could have owned a Frieling.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: